Get involved in YOUR city and locality - Improve Your World
Get involved in YOUR city and locality - Improve Your World
Get involved in YOUR city and locality 
Improve Your World Home | About Us | Sitemap | Search | Contact Us 



Home >> Hawkers >> Civil Appeal No. 4156-4157/2002

 
 

 
O R D E R 
Issue notice.
List on 26th October, 2005.
                              
 
ITEM NO.1                    COURT NO.4                     SECTION IX  
              S U P R E M E   C O U R T   O F   I N D I A 
                           RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS 
Civil Appeal No. 4156-4157/2002
 
MAHARASHTRA EKTA HAWKWERS UNION & ANR.                      Petitioner(s)
                        VERSUS
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,GREATER MUMBAI&ORS                    Respondent(s) 
(With appln. For intervention and permission to submit additional documents and 
intervention and modification of Court's Order and Judgment dated 09.12.2003 and 
clarification of Court's Order dated 09.03.2003 and 30.07.2004 and permission to file affidavit and
directions and impleadment)
With I.A. Nos. 136-137 (for permission to file addl.documents)
With C.A.No.4158-4159/2002 
C.A.No.4161-4162/2002 
( With appln. for permission to file additional documents and directions ) 
C.A.No.4163-4164/2002
C.A.No.4160/2002 
C.A.No.4170-4171/2002
C.A.No.4167-4169/2002
 With appln.for intervention  )
 
C.A.No.4165-4166/2002
C.A.No.4175-4176/2002
( With appln. for directions and permission to file rejoinder 
affidavit and permission to file list of hawkers )
C.A.No.4179-4180/2002
( With appln. for clarification/modification of Court's Order )
C.A.No.4172-4174/2002
( With appln. for directions )
CONMT.PET.(Civil)No.195-196/2001 in CA Nos. 4175-4176/2002
 
C.A.No.4178/2002
C.A.No.4177/2002 
C.A.No.9661/2003 
C.A.No.9662/2003
C.A.No.9663-9666/2003( With office report ) 
C.A.No.9667/2003
( With appln. for clarification/modification of Court's Order
dated 30.07.2004  and intervention and office report )
 
CONMT.PET.(Civil)No.456-458/2002 in CA No. 4167-4169/2002 
CONMT.PET.(C)No. 153-154/2005 in CA Nos. 4156-4157/2002 
Date: 27/09/2005  These Appeals were called on for hearing today. 
CORAM :
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE S.N. VARIAVA 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE TARUN CHATTERJEE
  For Appellant (s) Mr. Sushil Kumar Jain,Adv.
  In CAs 4156-57/02,            Ms. Pratibha Jain, Adv. 
  4161-62/02,          Mr. A.P.Dhamija, Adv. 
  4163-4164/02,        Mr. Ram V.Singh, Adv.
  4175-4176/02,        Mr. Ram Niwas, Adv. 
  4172-4174/02,        Mr. Sarad Singhania, Adv. 
  CP 195-196/01,       Mr. H.D.Thanvi, Adv.
  CA 4178/02 &         Mr. Puneet Jain, Adv.
  4177/02              Mr. L.P.Singh, Adv. 
  IA No.81-82/05 in
  in CA 4156-57/02 &            Mr. Shivaji M. Jadhav, Adv.
  for Appellants in
  CA 4158-4159/02
  For Appellant in Mr. M.N.Shroff, Adv.
  CA 4160/2002
  in CA 4170-4171/02            Mr. Shakil Ahmed Syed, Adv.
  in CA 4167-4169/02            Mr. Vijay Hansaria, Sr. Adv.
                                Mr. P.I.Jose, Adv.
                                Mr. K.S.Bhati, Adv.
                                Mr. Anupam Mishra, Adv. 
                                                        
 in CA 4165-4166/02              Mr. V.N. Ganpule, Sr. Adv. 
                                  Mr. Ashok Kumar Singh, Adv. 
  in CA 4179-4180/02
                                  Mr. Bharat Sangal, Adv.
  in CA 9662/2003
                                  Mr. Abhay Thorat, Adv.
                                  Mr. Venkateswara Rao Anumolu, Adv.
  in CA 9663-9666/03              Mr. Vimal Chandra S.Dave, Adv.
  in CA 9667/2003
                                  Mr. Vijay Kumar, Adv.


 

 
  In CA 9661/2003 &


 
  in CP 456-458/02 Mr. Sunil Kumar Jain, Adv.


 

 
  in CP 153-154/2005              Ms. Indira Jaising, Sr.Adv.


 
                                  Mr. Anand Grover, Adv.


 
                                  Mr. Ravindra Gidiya, Adv.


 
                                  Mr. Naveen R.Nath, Adv.


 
                                  Ms. Lalit Mohini Bhat, Adv.


 

 
  For Respondent (s)              Mr. G.E.Vahanvati, SG


 
                                  Mr. Pallav Shishodia, Adv.


 
                                  Ms. A.V.Patil, Adv.


 
                     Mr. D.N. Mishra,Adv.


 

 
  For State of         Mr. V.N.Raghupathy, Adv.


 
  Maharashtra        Mr. Ravindra K.Adsure, Adv.


 
                                  Mr. Mukesh K. Giri,Adv.


 

 
                                  Mr. R.S.Dhull, Adv.


 
                     Mr. Debasis Misra,Adv.


 

 
                                  Mr. U.Hazarika, Adv.


 
                                  Ms. Sumita Hazarika, Adv.


 

 
  For UOI                         Mr. P.P.Khurana, Sr.Adv.


 
                                  Mr. Vijay Panjwani, Adv.


 
                                  Mr. S.A.Matto, Adv.


 
                     Mr. V.K. Verma,Adv.


 
                                  Mr. P.Parmeswaran, Adv.


 

 
                                  Mr. Sushil K.Tekriwal, Adv.


 
                                  Mr. Rajeev K. Panday, Adv.


 

 
                                    4


 

 
           Mr. Ruby Singh Ahuja, Adv.


 

 
           Mr. Tatini Basu, Adv.


 
           Mr. Sudhir Nandrajog, Adv.


 

 
           Mr. Rohan Thawani, Adv.


 
           Mr. Joseph Pookkatt, Adv. 


 
           Mr. Prashant Kumar, Adv.


 

 
           Mr. Sushil Kumar Jain,Adv.


 
           Ms. Pratibha Jain, Adv.


 
           Mr. A.P.Dhamija, Adv.


 
           Mr. Ram V.Singh, Adv.


 
           Mr. Ram Niwas, Adv.


 
           Mr. Sarad Singhania, Adv.


 
           Mr. H.D.Thanvi, Adv.


 
           Mr. Puneet Jain, Adv.


 
           Mr. L.P.Singh, Adv.


 

 
           Mr. Uday B. Dube, Adv.


 
           Mr. Kuldip Singh, Adv.


 

 
           Ms. Hema Sahu, Adv. 


 
           Mr. C.L. Sahu, Adv. 


 

 
           Mr. R.D. Rathore, Adv. 


 
           Dr. Kailash Chand, Adv.


 

 
           Mr. Vijay Kumar, Adv.


 

 
           Mr. P.Ramesh Kumar, Adv.


 
           Ms. Aparna Bhat, Adv.


 
           Mr. Nitesh Kumar Singh, Adv.


 

 
           Mr. K.Rajeev, Adv.


 

 
           Mr. Sandeep Narain, Adv. 


 
           Mr. Shri Narain, Adv. for


 
           M/s. S.Narain & Co.


 

 
           Mr. Bharat Sangal, Adv.


 

 
           Ms. Nandini Gore, Adv.


 

 
           Mr. Senthil Jagadeesan, Adv. 


 
           Mr. V.Ramasubramanian, Adv.


 

 
           Mr. Pradeep Kumar Bakshi, Adv.


 

 
           Mr. S.V.Deshpande, Adv.


 

 
           Mr. Satyajit Saha, Adv. 


 

 
                                                                5


 

 
                                        Mrs.V.D.Khanna, Adv.


 

 
                                        Mr. Shivaji M. Jadhav, Adv.


 

 
                                        Mr. Rohit Alex, Adv.


 
                                        Ms. Shakun Sharma, Adv. for


 
                                        M/s. P.H.Parekh & Co.


 

 
                                        Ms. Asha Gopalan Nair, Adv.


 

 

 

 

 
                                        Ms. Indira Jaising, Sr.Adv.


 
                                        Mr. Anand Grover, Adv.


 
                                        Mr. Ravindra Gidiya, Adv.


 
                                        Mr. Naveen R.Nath, Adv.


 
                                        Ms. Lalit Mohini Bhat, Adv.


 

 
                                        Mr. Nikhil Nayyar, Adv.


 

 
                                        Mr. Prashant Bhushan, Adv.


 

 

 

 
           UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following


 
                               O R D E R 


 

 
             List on 26th October, 2005.


 

 
             Copies of the Report of the Committee to be given to the parties who apply  for it on payment
of  charges.     Even   the   Report  of  the   Three  Member  Hawking   Zone  Committee,  Western   
Region   to  be supplied to the parties who apply on payment of charges as and when it is received by this Court.


 
 
            Copy of the National Policy on Urban Street Vendors to be also given to the parties who apply 
for it on payment of charges.


 

 

 

 
                              Anita                                         (Jasbir Singh)


 
                                                                              Court Master


 

 
                                                                6


 

 
ITEM NO.1                    COURT NO.4                     SECTION IX


 

 

 

 
              S U P R E M E   C O U R T   O F   I N D I A


 
                           RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS


 
                      


 

 
I.A. No......./2005 in Civil Appeal Nos.4156-4157 of 2002 


 

 

 

 
MAHARASHTRA EKTA HAWKWERS UNION & ANR.                      Petitioner(s)


 

 
                        VERSUS


 

 
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,GREATER MUMBAI&ORS                    Respondent(s)


 
(Application for intervention)


 

 

 

 
Date: 27/09/2005  These Appeals were called on for hearing today.


 

 

 

 
CORAM :


 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE S.N. VARIAVA


 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE TARUN CHATTERJEE


 

 

 

 
  


 
  For Applicant (s) Mr. M.P.Vashi, Adv.


 
                                        Mr. M.N.Shroff, Adv.


 
                                        Mr. Asif Ali, Adv.


 
 


 
  For Respondent (s)


 

 

 

 
           UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following


 
                               O R D E R 


 

 
                List in the normal course.


 

 
                It is clarified that there is no stay.


 

 

 

 

 
                              Anita                                       (Jasbir Singh)


 
                                                                           Court Master


 

 
                                                             7


 

 
ITEM NO.1                    COURT NO.4                     SECTION IX


 

 

 

 
              S U P R E M E   C O U R T   O F   I N D I A


 
                           RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS


 
                      


 

 
I.A. Nos. 74-75/2004 in Civil Appeal Nos.4156-4157 of 2002 


 

 

 

 
MAHARASHTRA EKTA HAWKWERS UNION & ANR.                      Petitioner(s)


 

 
                        VERSUS


 

 
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,GREATER MUMBAI&ORS                    Respondent(s)


 
(Application for direction)


 

 

 

 
Date: 27/09/2005  These Appeals were called on for hearing today.


 

 

 

 
CORAM :


 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE S.N. VARIAVA


 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE TARUN CHATTERJEE


 

 
  


 
  For Applicant (s) Mr. V.N.Ganpule, Sr.Adv.


 
                                          Mr. Ashok Kumar Singh, Adv.


 

 
 


 
  For Respondent (s)


 

 

 

 
           UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following


 
                               O R D E R 


 

 
                Issue notice.


 

 
                In the meantime, it is clarified that the Order of this Court will prevail over the Order, 
if any,passed by the Civil Court subsequent to this Court's Order. 


 

 

 

 

 
                                 Anita                                       (Jasbir Singh)


 
                                                                               Court Master


 

 
                                                              8


 

 
ITEM NO.1                    COURT NO.4                     SECTION IX


 

 

 

 
              S U P R E M E   C O U R T   O F   I N D I A


 
                           RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS


 
                      


 

 
I.A. Nos.134-135/2005 in Civil Appeal Nos.4156-4157 of 2002 


 

 

 

 
MAHARASHTRA EKTA HAWKWERS UNION & ANR.                      Petitioner(s)


 

 
                        VERSUS


 

 
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,GREATER MUMBAI&ORS                    Respondent(s)


 
(Application for intervention)


 

 

 

 
Date: 27/09/2005  These Appeals were called on for hearing today.


 

 

 

 
CORAM :


 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE S.N. VARIAVA


 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE TARUN CHATTERJEE


 

 

 

 
  


 
  For Applicant (s)


 
                                          Mr. E.C.Agrawala, Adv.

 
  For Respondent (s)

 
           UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following 
                               O R D E R  
                Issue notice. 
                List on 26th October, 2005. 
                                 Anita                                    (Jasbir Singh)
 
                                                                           Court Master
 
                                                             9

 
ITEM NO.1                    COURT NO.4                     SECTION IX

 

 
              S U P R E M E   C O U R T   O F   I N D I A

 
                           RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

 
I.A. Nos.79-80 in I.A No. 42-43 in Civil Appeal Nos.4156-4157 of 2002 

 
MAHARASHTRA EKTA HAWKWERS UNION & ANR.                      Petitioner(s)

 
                        VERSUS

 
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,GREATER MUMBAI&ORS                    Respondent(s)


 
(Application for clarification/Direction on behalf of Applicant
Association National Disabled Organization for Court's Order
dated 30/07/2004)

 
Date: 27/09/2005  These Appeals were called on for hearing today.
 
CORAM : 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE S.N. VARIAVA

 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE TARUN CHATTERJEE 


 
  For Applicant (s) 
                                          Mr. Vijay Kumar, Adv.
 
  For Respondent (s)

 
           UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following
                               O R D E R 
 
                Issue notice.

 
                List on 26th October, 2005.
 

 
                                 Anita                                    (Jasbir Singh)


 
                                                                           Court Master

 
                                                             10

ITEM NO.1                    COURT NO.4                     SECTION IX

 
              S U P R E M E   C O U R T   O F   I N D I A
 
                           RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

 
I.A. No. 5 in Civil Appeal No. 9667/2003

 
AKHIL BHARTIYA CHARMAKAR SENA & ANR.                        Petitioner(s)

 
                        VERSUS
 
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,GREATER MUMBAI&ORS                    Respondent(s)
 
(Application for clarification of Order dated 30/07/2004)
 
Date: 27/09/2005  This Appeal was called on for hearing today.
 
CORAM :
 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE S.N. VARIAVA 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE TARUN CHATTERJEE 


 
  For Applicant (s) 
                                          Mr. Vijay Kumar, Adv.

 
  For Respondent (s)

 
           UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following
 
                               O R D E R 

 
                Issue notice.

 
                List on 26th October, 2005.

 
                                 Anita                                    (Jasbir Singh)
 
                                                                           Court Master
                                                             11 

 
ITEM NO.1                    COURT NO.4                     SECTION IX

 
              S U P R E M E   C O U R T   O F   I N D I A 
                           RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS
 
I.A. No. 6 in Civil Appeal No. 9667/2003
 
AKHIL BHARTIYA CHARMAKAR SENA & ANR.                        Petitioner(s)
 
                        VERSUS
 
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,GREATER MUMBAI&ORS                    Respondent(s)
 
Date: 27/09/2005  This Appeal was called on for hearing today. 
CORAM :
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE S.N. VARIAVA 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE TARUN CHATTERJEE

 
  For Applicant (s) 
                                          Mr. Vijay Kumar, Adv.
  For Respondent (s)

 
           UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following 
                               O R D E R 
 
                Issue notice.
 
                List on 26th October, 2005.

 
                                 Anita                                    (Jasbir Singh) 
                                                                           Court Master
                                                             12

 
ITEM NO.1                    COURT NO.4                     SECTION IX

 
              S U P R E M E   C O U R T   O F   I N D I A
 
                           RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

 
I.A. Nos. 42-43 in Civil Appeal Nos.4156-4157 of 2002 
 
MAHARASHTRA EKTA HAWKWERS UNION & ANR.                      Petitioner(s)
                        VERSUS
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,GREATER MUMBAI&ORS                    Respondent(s)
 
Date: 27/09/2005  These Appeals were called on for hearing today.

 
CORAM :
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE S.N. VARIAVA 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE TARUN CHATTERJEE
 
  For Applicant (s) 
                                          Mr. Vijay Kumar, Adv.
  For Respondent (s) 
           UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following 
                               O R D E R  
                Issue notice.
 
                List on 26th October, 2005.
 
                                 Anita                                    (Jasbir Singh)
 
                                                                           Court Master

 
                                                                13

 
ITEM NO.1                    COURT NO.4                     SECTION IX

 
              S U P R E M E   C O U R T   O F   I N D I A

 
                           RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

 
I.A. Nos.18-20 in Civil Appeal Nos. 4167-4169 of 2002
 
BOMBAY  HAWKERS  ASSOCIATION                                  Petitioner(s)
 
                        VERSUS
 
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,GREATER MUMBAI&ORS                    Respondent(s)
(Application for Directions)
Date: 27/09/2005  These Appeals were called on for hearing today. 
CORAM :
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE S.N. VARIAVA 
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE TARUN CHATTERJEE
 
  For Applicant (s)
                                          Mr. P.I.Jose, Adv. 
  For Respondent (s)
 
           UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following
                               O R D E R 
                Issue notice.
 
                List on 26th October, 2005.

 
                                 Anita                                    (Jasbir Singh) 
                                                                           Court Master
                                                                14
ITEM NO.1                    COURT NO.4                     SECTION IX
 
              S U P R E M E   C O U R T   O F   I N D I A
                           RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS
 
I.A. Nos. 21-23 in Civil Appeal Nos. 4167-4169 of 2002
 
BOMBAY  HAWKERS  ASSOCIATION                                  Petitioner(s)

                        VERSUS

 
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,GREATER MUMBAI&ORS                    Respondent(s)
 
(Application for Directions)

 
Date: 27/09/2005  These Appeals were called on for hearing today.
CORAM :
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE S.N. VARIAVA
        HON'BLE  MR. JUSTICE TARUN CHATTERJEE 
  For Applicant (s)
                                          Mr. P.I.Jose, Adv.
  For Respondent (s)
           UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following
                               O R D E R 
                Issue notice.
                List on 26th October, 2005. 
                                 Anita                                    (Jasbir Singh) 
                                                                           Court Master






It is one of the beautiful compensations of this life that no one can sincerely try to help another without helping himself. --Charles Dudley Warner