Get involved in YOUR city and locality - Improve Your World
Get involved in YOUR city and locality - Improve Your World
Get involved in YOUR city and locality 
Improve Your World Home | About Us | Sitemap | Search | Contact Us 



Home >> Hawkers >> Supreme Court's Order on   1-4-2005

 

Supreme Court's Order on   1-4-2005 C.A.No. 4156-4157 OF 2002

 
O R D E R 

Office to issue notice to them as to why action in contempt should not be taken against them for instigating hawkers to act against Orders passed by this Court and for preventing implementation of the scheme framed by this Court. 

        The Police is directed to give full and complete protection to the Municipal staff as and when they go to clear the hawkers as per the directions of this Court. It will be the duty of the Commissioner of Police, Greater Bombay to see that such protection is given. The Police Commissioner shall also ensure that there is regular patrolling to ensure that once the hawkers are removed from a particular place, they do not come back to that place.

        It appears that apart from a sum of Rs. 3,000/- provided for in our Order in the case of Maharashtra Ekta Hawkers Union & Anr. vs. Municipal Corporation, Greater Mumbai & Ors. reported in (2004) 1 SCC 625, the Committee is demanding a further sum of Rs. 1,500/- from citizens' group or others who appear either to support or to object to the proposals being considered by the Committee.  It is clarified that the Committee will not be entitled to charge any further or other amount from such persons or groups. All that the Chairman of Committee will be entitled to is the sum of Rs. 3,000/- as provided in our above said Order.  

        The Committee must also work out a procedure by which the dates of hearing are made known to the public and the result or their decision is also made known to all parties particularly those who had participated before the Committee.

        List on 26th July, 2005.

        Copies of all the reports which have been received by this Court to be given to all parties who apply for the same.
 


                              
C.A.No. 4156-4157 OF 2002

ITEM 

No.24                   Court No.

 5                  SECTION IX

                                                          


 

 
                S U P R E M E   C O U R T   O F   I N D I A

                          RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS


 

 
  Civil Appeal No.4156-4157/2002


 

 
  MAHARASHTRA EKTA HAWKWERS 
UNION
 & ANR.                    Appellant (s)


 
                              VERSUS


 
  MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,GREATER MUMBAI&ORS                  Respondent (s)

  ( With appln. for intervention and permission to submit

  additional document(s) and modification of Court's Order

  and Judgment dated 09.12.2003 and directions and clarification

  of Court's Order and accepting English translation and 

  modification/clarification of Court's Order dated 09.12.2003

  and permission to file affidavit and modification of Court's

  Order dated 30.07.2004 and clarification/directions of Court's

  Order dated 30.07.2004 and impleadment/intervention and

  permission to file affidavit for the purpose of replying to

  the reports and exemption from filing O.T. )

  WITH I.A. Nos. 110-111 (Appln. for direction) and

  I.A.Nos. 112-113 (Appln. for stay)

 

  With


 
 C.A.No.4158-4159/2002


 
 C.A.No.4161-4162/2002

 ( With appln. for permission to file additional documents )


 
 C.A.No.4163-4164/2002

 ( With appln. for directions and modification/clarification

 and permission to file addl. documents )


 
 C.A.No.4160/2002


 
 C.A.No.4170-4171/2002


 
 C.A.No.4167-4169/2002

 ( With appln.for intervention )

 With I.A. Nos. 15-17 (Appln. for intervention)


 
 C.A.No.4165-4166/2002

 

 C.A.No.4175-4176/2002

 ( With appln. for permission to file rejoinder affidavit and

 permission to file additional documents and directions and

 permission to file list of hawkers )


 
 C.A.No.4179-4180/2002

 

 C.A.No.4172-4174/2002

 ( With appln. for directions )

 

 CONMT.PET.(Civil)No.195-196/2001


 
 C.A.No.4178/2002


 
 C.A.No.4177/2002


 
 C.A.No.9661/2003


 
 C.A.No.9662/2003


 
 C.A.No.9663-9666/2003

 ( With prayer for interim relief and office report )


 
 C.A.No.9667/2003

 ( With appln. for clarification/modification of Court's Order

 and intervention and office report )


 
 CONMT.PET.(Civil)No.456-458/2002


 

 
  Date : 01/04/2005 These Petitions were called on for hearing today.


 

 
  CORAM :

           HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.N. VARIAVA                  

           HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.K. SEMA                     

                                                             


 
  For Appellant (s)    Mr. Sushil Kumar Jain,Adv.

  In CAs 4156-57/02,   Mr. H.D.Thanvi, Adv.

  4161-62/02, 

  4163-4164/02, 

  4175-4176/02, 

  4172-4174/02,

  CP 195-196/01,

  CA 4178/02 &

  4177/02


 
  IA No.81-82/05 in    Mr. Shekhar Naphade, Sr. Adv.

  in CA 4156-57/02 &   Mr. Shivaji M. Jadhav, Adv.

  for Appellants in    Mr. Himanshu Gupta, Adv.

  CA 4158-4159/02      Mr. Brij Sah, Adv. 

                       


 
  For Appellant in     Mr. M.N.Shroff, Adv.

  CA 4160/2002


 
  in CA 4170-4171/02   Mr. Shakil Ahmed Syed, Adv.


 

 
  in CA 4167-4169/02   Mr. Vijay Hansaria, Sr. Adv.

                       Mr. P.I.Jose, Adv.

                       Mr. Anupam Mishra, Adv. 

                       Mr. Jenis, Adv. 


 
  in CA 4165-4166/02   Mr. V.N. Ganpule, Sr. Adv.

                       Mr. Ashok Kumar Singh, Adv. 

                       Mr. Sapam Biswajit Meitei, Adv. 

        

  in CA 4179-4180/02   Mr. Anand Grover, Adv.

                       Mr. Bharat Sangal, Adv.

                       Ms. Sangeeta Panicker, Adv.

                       Mr. R.R.Kumar, Adv.

                       Mr. Samyadip Chatterji, Adv.


 
  in CA 9662/2003      Mr. Sushil Karanjkar, Adv.

                       Mr. Abhay Thorat, Adv.

                       Mr. Venkateswara Rao Anumolu, Adv.

                       

  in CA 9663-9666/03   Mr. Vimal Chandra S.Dave, Adv.

        

  in CA 9667/2003      Mr. Dinesh C.Shah, Adv.

                       Mr. Vijay Kumar, Adv.

                       Mr. Ashwani Garg, Adv.         


 
  In CA 9661/2003 &

  in CP 456-458/02     Mr. Sunil Kumar Jain, Adv.

                       

  For Respondent (s)   Mr. G.E.Vahanvati, SG

                       Mr. Bhimrao N.Naik, Sr.Adv.

                        Mr. D.N. Mishra,Adv.

                       Mr. Pallav Shishodia, Adv.

                       Mr. S.H.Ujjainwala, Adv.

                       Mr. M.V.Patil, Adv.            


 
  For State of         

Mr. S.S.Shinde

, Adv.

  
Maharashtra
           Mr. Mukesh K. Giri,Adv.


 
                       Mr. R.S.Dhull, Adv.

                        Mr. Debasis Misra,Adv.


 
                       Mr. Vijay Panjwani, Adv.

                       Mr. P.P.Khurana, Adv.

                        Mr. V.K. Verma,Adv.


 
                       Mr. V.N.Raghupathy, Adv.

                       Mr. Rajeev Panday, Adv.

                       Mr. Sushil K.Tekriwal, Adv.


 
                       Mr. Ruby Singh Ahuja, Adv.


 
                       Mr. V.N. Ganpule, Sr. Adv.

                       Mr. Ashok Kumar Singh, Adv. 

                       Mr. Sapam Biswajit Meitei, Adv. 

        

                       Mr. Sudhir Nandrajog, Adv.


 
                       Mr. P.Parmeswaran, Adv.


 
                       Mr. Rohan Thawani, Adv.

                       Mr. Joseph Pookkatt, Adv. 

                       Mr. Prashant Kumar, Adv.


 
                       Ms. Pratibha Jain, Adv.


 
                       Mr. K.K. Singhvi, Sr. Adv.

                       Mr. Susheel Mahadeshwar, Adv. 

                       Mr. Uday B. Dube, Adv.

                       Mr. Kuldip Singh, Adv.


 
                       Ms. Hema Sahu, Adv. 

                       Mr. C.L. Sahu, Adv. 

                       Mr. R.D. Rathore, Adv. 

                       Dr. Kailash Chand, Adv.


 
                       Mr. Dinesh C.Shah, Adv.

                       Mr. Vijay Kumar, Adv.

                       Mr. Ashwani Garg, Adv.


 
                       Mr. Colin Gonsalves, Sr.Adv.

                       Ms. Aparna Bhat, Adv.

                       Mr. P.Ramesh Kumar, Adv.


 
                       Mr. K.Rajeev, Adv.


 
                       Mr. J.F. Pochkhanawalla, Sr.Adv.

                       Mr. Shri Narain, Adv. 

                       Mr. Sandeep Narain, Adv. 

                       Ms. Anjali Jha, Adv. for 

                       M/s. S.Narain & Co.


 
                       Mr. Anand Grover, Adv.

                       Mr. Bharat Sangal, Adv.

                       Ms. Sangeeta Panicker, Adv.

                       Mr. R.R.Kumar, Adv.

                       Mr. Samyadip Chatterji, Adv.


 
                       Ms. Nandini Gore, Adv.


 
                       Mr. Samist Mistry, Adv.

                       Mr. Senthil Jagadeesan, Adv. 

                       Mr. V.Ramasubramanian, Adv.


 
                       Mr. Shyam Diwan, Adv.

                       Ms. Madhavi Divan, Adv.

                       Mr. Pradeep Kumar Bakshi, Adv.


 
                       Mr. S.V.Deshpande, Adv.


 

 
                       Mr. Satyajit Saha, Adv. 

                       Mrs.V.D.Khanna, Adv.


 
                       Mr. Shivaji M. Jadhav, Adv.

                       Mr. Himanshu Gupta, Adv. 

                       Mr. Brij Kishore Sah, Adv. 


 

 
        UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following

                            O R D E R 

        Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay have supplied the names and addresses of six following persons:-

1. Shri Suresh Mahadev Kapile,

 21/175, Unnat Nagar, M.G.Road,

 Goregaon, Mumbai-400 064


 
        2.Shri Ramaswami Unnarappa Gauda,

          Sumangal Co-op. Hsg.Society

          Room No. 1, Dindayal Cross Road,

          Dombivali (West) Distt.Thane.


 
        3.Shri Dinbandhu Maurya,

          2/203, Asav Palav, 

          Kasturi Park, Navghar Road,

          Bhaindar (East), Distt.Thane


 
        4.Shri Vasant Tukra Salian,

          Queens Mansion, 4th Floor,

          Room No. 18, Bldg. No.44,

          Amrut Keshav Marg,

          Fort, Mumbai-400 001.


 
        5.Shri Shakil Ahemad Mohassin Shaikh, 

          Dr. Zakir Hussain Nagar Zopadpatti, 

          Mankhurd Link Road,

          Mumbai-400 043


 
        6.Shri Narendra Kashinath Nirgudkar, 

          Parijat Society, New Mhada Complex,

          Bldg. No.19 A, Room No. 4,

          Borivali (East), Mumbai-400 066.


 
Office to issue notice to them as to why action in contempt should not be taken against them 
for instigating hawkers to act against Orders passed by this Court and for preventing implementation of the 
scheme framed by this Court.

        The Police is directed to give full and complete protection to the Municipal staff as and 
when they go to clear the hawkers as per the directions of this Court.  
It will be the duty of the Commissioner of Police, Greater Bombay to see that such protection is given.  
The Police Commissioner shall also ensure that there is regular patrolling to ensure that once the hawkers are 
removed from a particular place, they do not come back to that place.

        It appears that apart from a sum of Rs. 3,000/- provided for in our Order in the case of 
Maharashtra Ekta Hawkers Union & Anr. vs. Municipal Corporation, Greater Mumbai & Ors. reported in (2004) 1 SCC 625, 
the Committee is demanding a further sum of Rs. 1,500/- from citizens' group or others who appear either to support 
or to object to the proposals being considered by the Committee.  It is clarified that the Committee will not be entitled 
to charge any further or other amount from such persons or groups. 
All that the Chairman of Committee will be entitled to is the sum of Rs. 3,000/- as provided in our above said Order.  

        The Committee must also work out a procedure by which the dates of hearing are made known to the public and 
the result or their decision is also made known to all parties particularly those who had participated before the Committee.

        List on 26th July, 2005.

        Copies of all the reports which have been received by this Court to be given to all parties who apply for the same.


 
        

        

Anita


 
(Jasbir Singh)

Court Master

 




It is one of the beautiful compensations of this life that no one can sincerely try to help another without helping himself. --Charles Dudley Warner